I ordered color #2 deep brown. It goes on smooth and can be applied thick or thin.It does bleed slightly while still wet but once it dries it stays in place.On my hand it stays in place even after multiple hand washes but on my eye lids it cracks a little on the edges and I can scratch it off a little.I can apply this very precisely with the tip too.While I put on, when it's still drying, it does irritate my eyes a little.

I love the point on this eyeliner. The precision tip is just amazing, and the ability to lay the eyeliner sideways and make for a more dramatic line is awesome. That flexibility is really nice, especially for someone who normally resorts to pencil liners to get the desired control.I did have trouble with the "waterproof" aspect - you definitely have to shake the eyeliner more than five times to get any sort of waterproof experience, and even then, I didn't find that the eyeliner quite stuck it out. I have to put eye drops in throughout the day, and I end up with a rather smudged look, instead of the finely-drawn eye the pen tip originally offered.I wish the formula had been up to the tool - the pen itself is amazing. I'll definitely wear this on days where I'm just going out for short events, and don't have to put drops in.

I’ve been using liquid eyeliner for 10+ years now and this one is the winner for sure, and at a very affordable price too! My only complaint is the packaging: the white stripe print on the pen’s body peels off after a while and stick to my fingers and sometimes face and is very hard to wipe off, like glitters. If the pen is in my cosmetic bag, everything else inside would get this tiny peelings on it. I hope they will consider simplify the packaging so it doesn’t create a mess that’s impossible to clean. Other than that, I love this liner!

I love the point on this eyeliner. The precision tip is just amazing, and the ability to lay the eyeliner sideways and make for a more dramatic line is awesome. That flexibility is really nice, especially for someone who normally resorts to pencil liners to get the desired control.I did have trouble with the "waterproof" aspect - you definitely have to shake the eyeliner more than five times to get any sort of waterproof experience, and even then, I didn't find that the eyeliner quite stuck it out. I have to put eye drops in throughout the day, and I end up with a rather smudged look, instead of the finely-drawn eye the pen tip originally offered.I wish the formula had been up to the tool - the pen itself is amazing. I'll definitely wear this on days where I'm just going out for short events, and don't have to put drops in.

Well, it’s definitely long lasting, and it definitely stays where you put it....so apply carefully, because if you make a mistake you’ll need a cleanser or eye makeup remover to fix it. The brush is small and flat, making application pretty simple. All in all, this is a pretty good eyeliner!