WATERPROOF PENCIL EYELINER

(1356 customer reviews)

NET WT. 0.012 OZ. / 0.35 g

$9.00

Wishlist Please, enable Built-in Wishlist.

Highlights

Long-lasting

Waterproof

Smooth

Shimmery

About the Product

This smudge-free waterproof eyeliner glides on smoothly and it provides perfect, long-lasting lines from morning to night.

How to use

– Twist the bottom part to dispense the eyeliner as needed, and trace it along the upper and lower lash line.
– Close the cap after use.

 

Ingredients & Warning

Ingredients

Cyclopentasiloxane, Iron Oxides (CI 77499), Trimethylsiloxysilicate, Calcium Sodium Borosilicate, Ceresin, Polyethylene, Cyclohexasiloxane, Diphenylsiloxy Phenyl Trimethicone, Mica (CI 77019), Euphorbia Cerifera (Candelilla) Wax, Sucrose Tetrastearate Triacetate, Disteardimonium Hectorite, Phenoxyethanol, Titanium Dioxide (CI 77891), Propylene Carbonate, Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil, Persea Gratissima (Avocado) Oil, Tin Oxide

Warning

For external use only. Do not use on damaged or broken skin. Discontinue use if rash occurs during or after use. If in eyes, rinse eyes thoroughly with water. Do not store in extreme temperature or under direct sunlight. Keep out of reach of children.

1356 reviews for WATERPROOF PENCIL EYELINER

  1. Donna (verified owner) –

    This is my favorite eyeliner ! I received a sample of this eyeliner in my Ipsy bag. I loved how silky and easily it went on and the glimmer in it. So I ordered a full size in 2 colors. I love them.

  2. Anonymous (verified owner) –

    Love this eyeliner

  3. Kim L. (verified owner) –

    I received a small version of this liner in my Ipsy bag and just loved it. I love the shimmer so I looked on the pencil and noticed a website. So I ordered myself 2 full size liners

  4. Janice K. (verified owner) –

    Best eyeliner, especially for the water line. Completes the whole look

  5. Tracie (verified owner) –

    I love this eyeliner! It is the best one I have ever had. I received my first one through Ipsy. I loved it from day one. Went on so smoothly, no tugging. Stayed put all day. I was so glad I was able to track it down when the pencil got so low that all that was left was your web address.

  6. Mary Cisneros (verified owner) –

    no smears and long lasting!

  7. Katie D. (verified owner) –

    Received this eyeliner in one of my Ipsy bags. This eyeliner deserves an award. I have an extremely hard time keeping any eyeliner on my water line, but when I tell you this stuff doesn’t budge, run, fade or smear, I mean it! As long as they keep making it, I will keep buying it!

  8. Jennifer T. (verified owner) –

    It’s waterproof but it doesn’t stay on my lower lid

  9. Rhonda S. (verified owner) –

    I love this eyeliner. It actually stays on!!

  10. Morgan D. (verified owner) –

    I love this eyeliner! It goes on smooth and lasts all day. Plus it has shimmer!

  11. CJ (verified owner) –

    Originally got from Ipsy, now I will always buy this eyeliner. This is the ONLY eyeliner that I’ve put on my water line that stays in place no matter what. Most eyeliners start to smear in the corners. This literally L.O.C.K’s in place! LOVE IT!

  12. Anonymous (verified owner) –

    The 3 eyeliners I purchased is my all time favorite. It glides on smoothly, it turns so no sharpening is needed. It has a slight glitter which gives the eyeliner the pop it needs.

  13. Anonymous (verified owner) –

    This eyeliner is long lasting and highly pigmented, yet easy to blend and easy to wear. It’s my favorite look for eyes.

  14. Shelley Meade (verified owner) –

    Great. Product. Love this eye pencil. It is creamy, water proof, and just the right tip for lining!

  15. Vicky Simons (verified owner) –

    This is my favorite eye liner. I love it .

  16. Brandi Gomez (verified owner) –

    Ipsy sample….LOVE THIS PENCIL!! From the first use, I fell in love. Glides on so smoothly and the color is blacker than black. The shimmer is a beautiful touch.

  17. Sue J. (verified owner) –

    I love this product! It goes on smooth and it stays on, throughout the whole day!

  18. Katie –

    This is my FAVORITE eyeliner i have ever used. My mom gave me the sample eyeliner she recieved in a beauty box and i fell in love with this eyeliner. I used the entire sample and came to amazon to get another. The color has tiny specks of glitter in it and it really helps make your eyes pop and it glides on smooth. I also used it for my eyelids as well!

  19. Brenda Martinez (verified owner) –

    Nice!

  20. MO –

    I love this because it lasts all day, easy to apply and no raccoon eyes at the end of the day! I’ve tried and have a ton of eyeliners as well! I’m glad I took a chance and even more thankful it was originally in my Ipsy bag . Great product and very reasonably priced!!

  21. Candice Simpson –

    Love ❤️ THIS EYELINER!!! Only eyeliner for me from now on

  22. Sarah K. (verified owner) –

    Absolutely love this always keep

  23. Anonymous (verified owner) –

    Goes on smooth

  24. Abby –

    Glides nicely and has a good rich color but it made my eyes water and burn all day. Wasn’t able to use it more than once.

  25. Anonymous (verified owner) –

    I love how easily this blends and I love the glitter!

  26. Anonymous (verified owner) –

    ❤️👍

  27. Foster The Felines –

    The color is gorgeous and it has just enough cream to it it be able to blend it out a bit. It glides on easily and lasts all day

  28. Perla Gumm (verified owner) –

    Amaxing long lasting

  29. Patricia S. –

    Eyeliner stays put till you remove it. Easy to apply, great product 👌

  30. Rachel J (verified owner) –

    I love this eyeliner! I originally got it as a sample through Ipsy and had to get this!

  31. AJ (verified owner) –

    Goes on beautifully definitely my new favorite eyeliner

  32. Wendy (verified owner) –

    This is my new go to eyeliner. Goes on smooth with no creasing or flaking. So awesome I would give it a 10!!!

  33. Allie –

    This is my favorite eyeliner. Not as waterproof as it says but it looks nice for a couple hours.

  34. Mendy (verified owner) –

    I absolutely love this eyeliner!

  35. Sdriscoll92 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love

  36. zgraceb11411 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love eyeliners

  37. amandacalejo –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very nice eyeliner doesn’t stay super long on water lines but overall good eyeliner

  38. faore4 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very smooth and easy to apply, a bit lighter than I expected though

  39. agallegos241 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Cute

  40. Tcolville –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great long lasting eyeliner! I don’t need any more black- I’d love it if this brand made colorful eyeliners

  41. dmurrieta08 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Ok

  42. millerkim3715 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    love this eyeliner goes on smooth and doesnt wear off!!!

  43. deniedangel666 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love a good black pencil liner. Hoping this is truly waterproof

  44. YDK –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I wanted to love this. It looks rich and I was excited that it’s waterproof but I just doesn’t stay rich. It seems to fade. Ideal perhaps for a smudging look under your eyes.

  45. Jordynxoxoxo –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this shade

  46. missym0033 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not too bad. Does run when wearing a mask and glasses.

  47. sdangelo0921 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Slides on smoothly last all day.

  48. melrosew06 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on dark and smooth. The glitter is cute

  49. lambchop278 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Works well and goes on very smoothly!

  50. julieclare94 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the shade! Perfect for my lower lid and easily blendable. The sparkles add a nice accent!

  51. amayabunton12 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    love the way it glides on

  52. jeannie_baracy –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Best liner I’ve ever used! Love it!

  53. alh954 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Loved this and was sad it was so small lol. Will buy the full size. Only complaint is the glitter gets everywhere.

  54. emcjohnson33 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Glides on nice.

  55. 135doggg –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like black eyeliner but I really prefer brown

  56. livengoodkp –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love black pencil eyeliners, but this one was a little too shimmery for me. I do not like glittery, shimmery, products. It did last all day though without smearing. I would have rated it 5 stars if it wasn’t for the shimmer.

  57. davrph –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I have some difficulty using some eyeliners. This one glides on easy and I don’t end up with a smudgy mess like sometimes with other brands. Looks great and stays put throughout the day. I’m a fan!

  58. phantomqueen13 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Such a beautiful shade and so creamy

  59. SchmittyReed –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Loooove this. The although I’m not sure I own a pencil sharpener… it would be way better if this was a twist up.

  60. valstone111 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Wore this on my waterline hasn’t faded in 9 hours

  61. ajadef22803 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    i love how it applies and the look of it.

  62. dsbiosware –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice eyliner great shade

  63. annamaria41988 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Amazing pencil liner it glides pretty darn good and the black is very black a little too dark for me.

  64. kikibaby0415 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I have never liked a pencil eyeliner more. It very easy to draw on and stays long.

  65. gabi_htc_7 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Good color payoff

  66. lynds_willow –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Stayed good!

  67. jtinomaria –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Absolutely love it

  68. mflecha2203 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It doesnt go on strong on the bottom inside of the eye you have to go over it a few times but over all i like it

  69. fionamakou004 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice

  70. gloglo3k –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Creamy, long-wearing and I love the slight sparkles that give your eye a slight pop!

  71. tlancaster03 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I’m sure it’s okay for some people, but I use dark brown shade.

  72. nnpietri –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Was nice and dark in color and went on smoothly

  73. LuckyChance –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Yes! Another great black liner!! Never enough!’

  74. loriw2017 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Tip was broken off. IRRITATING!! This has happened with EVERY lip/eyeliner I have been sent from IPSY!!

  75. spence_angel15 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not dark enough for me

  76. mbarbay17 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This doesnt bleed! Glides on smooth perfect for the waterline.

  77. jmann7232000 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I usually go for brown eyeliners, but this color isn’t bad. I could see using it for an evening out sort of thing. I like the shimmer in it as well. It goes on very smoothly.

  78. britsmakeup –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on smoothly, longevity is pretty good. Doesnt smear with water (oily is a different story) good pigment.

  79. ceishen –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Glides like butter!

  80. iamsierradawn –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love any black eyeliner and this one works well.

  81. fnh987 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is very easy to use and doesn’t dry down too quickly, so you can smudge it or correct mistakes

  82. Bernadettesipsy –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great stay power but tough to feather/blend.

  83. valeria_carolna –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Lasted all day, and it applies really smooth

  84. latishaypage –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Perfect eyeliner for my brown eyes!!

  85. goldie1931 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Does it come in other shades? I love Brown the Best Tho.

  86. Thistaylor95 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I’m not into pencil, but I love this!

  87. Mrs_tiffany –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice pencil, good payoff

  88. martinacross126 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I rarely use eyeliner, but when I do, pencil always works best. This one glides on nice and easy!

  89. daniellepalmer33 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It’s a nice sparkly black eyeliner. It isn’t very pigmented however, but it’s a decent liner

  90. pochacho728 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Makes your eyes water at first if you put it on your waterline but stays put all day

  91. bernadettebarringer –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Too hard to open

  92. kristinacalafiore –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    wasn’t pigmented enough so it didn’t even show up on my waterline

  93. o4kbabymama –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Will keep this for my purse for on the go fixes. Can’t complain

  94. lisieboo16 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love

  95. thegingerdog3 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the liner it stays on and easy to apply would definitely recommend….Brenda

  96. addisonadam71 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on so smooth

  97. bluejonessa –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Finally a black liner that doesn’t run! 🥳🥳🥳

  98. mariele56121 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love eyeliners in general. I would rather get colors instead of black

  99. mxlxschmidt –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Perfect eyeliner. Goes on smooth and dark

  100. ka217408 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Went on smooth, but had a lot of glitter in it which I wasn’t expecting.

  101. 4dancingbulldogs53 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It’s sparkly!!!

  102. relgirl06 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great shade also long lasting wear for the color love this product

  103. laurie_dolbec11 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Really waterproof!

  104. eowen687 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on smooth.

  105. leetatum66 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Used once, and it did last all day, hallelujah

  106. hb306135 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    i love this shade and i love the shape of this pencil

  107. beccabrown777 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Vreat for your waterline doesnt run or smidge

  108. waxlily –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Shade was good and applies nicely but it smears and smudges very easily.

  109. kristeenbeck –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I don’t wear black eyeliner much anymore, this is very nice would be better if I would have received it in brown! Lol

  110. athenagreeneyes –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I wasn’t expecting the bit of sparkle in this eye liner, but luckily when I tried it on I was headed somewhere festive so it wasn’t inappropriate. It went on smoothly and stayed in place all day. It didn’t cause any irriration and washed off well. It was my first experience with this brand, but so far so good!

  111. ramya96sruthi –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Want to try different eyeliner colors

  112. Abond –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It’s ok

  113. jocelynwulff –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Survived a cry session!

  114. mckenna_mackay00 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Little sparkly but doesn’t smudge at all

  115. ashleydgriffin –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Another perfect 10, love love love

  116. pattyontiveros180 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    De una pasada queda muy bien el color

  117. GarvinST –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very nice and smooth.

  118. kassrocha10 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great item

  119. wks1022 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I don’t tend to wear eyeliner.

  120. combshope –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Was hoping for a deeper shade however this gives a shimmery effect that I was not expecting but enjoy.

  121. kbug10120 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love it so easy to Apply

  122. gaby_yajaira02 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It smooshes a bit but good

  123. knittasaurus –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this one goes on great and it’s super waterproof

  124. mandydeadite –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice eyeliner pencil. Shame it has glitter in it.

  125. tillotsontena25 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It does run a little. Not full water proof. But I do likeit.

  126. curran_savoy –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Get colour I love it

  127. vanbuskrikamanda –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like using liquid liners better but it does the job

  128. cozycarmen –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Probably one of the smallest eyeliners ever given out.

  129. daniferocious –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Pigmented darkest soul black eyeliner. What’s not to love?

  130. chloemay2008 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    i LOVE this! it go’s on so smooth and last super long!

  131. Dewild –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love the glide of gel

  132. tsauble –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on smooth and stays on all day. Great liner!

  133. rachel_harbisin –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like the formula its nice and creamy but i just didnt like the glitter in it

  134. crodriguez1591 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great for waterline!

  135. sylviaherrera –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I really like the gel water proof liners.

  136. jasminkasprzak –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the color glides on so smooth last all day

  137. lori_davis84 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like how smooth it goes on.

  138. amyboyd44 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the little bit of sparkle in this one.

  139. lissalay –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Glides on very smoothly. The color isn’t as deep as I like.

  140. dirtygirldiamonds –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great eyeliner

  141. waguespackwedding18 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like liquid liners more than pencil ones.

  142. JackieSue_07 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This was an easy to put on eyeliner. I’m not really a waterproof girl, but it did hold up like it should.

  143. flippytiff –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The sparkles were such a fun surprise and add a nice pop to the reliable black liner! It also lasted all day. Big win for me!

  144. audreyperkic –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    small asf

  145. sarzahlanier04 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    it busted open and all the product exploded

  146. leslieott4 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice liner

  147. dollfaces6988 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love it love the color

  148. chaineysgotmail –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not my favorite! Smudges throughout the day, but still hard to get off when you wash your face. The shade is pretty, but it just isn’t as long-wearing as I’d anticipated.

  149. daphanie_hayes –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I didn’t realize how shiny it was. Only issue.

  150. taabboo17 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Perfection

  151. christinelovestony –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this eyeliner was smooth to put on lasted all day really love this eyeliner

  152. moniblues –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Went on smooth and creamy and stayed in place, which is usually an issue for me with pencil eyeliners. Looking forward to using it some more.

  153. ivanova_enii –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not really good eyeliner, more like eye pencil

  154. Lanna1233 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The shade is a little bit sparkly, but the liner slides on easily and has a good black pigment. I don’t really use eyeliner.

  155. ms_cieva989 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Perfect shade. Good staying power! Would definitely purchase again!

  156. kayshot –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not very opaque & I find the glitter annoying all over my face but I do like how easily it glides into my skin, has good coverage & last all day.

  157. sattg2009 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    So silky and smooth honestly eye linears are a daily for me so it’s nice to have one that glides on with the perfect finish

  158. chrystalvandusseldor –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This beautiful! Very black with iridescent/holographic shimmer in it. And it is budge-proof and waterproof.

  159. rebecca_mizell –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It goes on smooth but throughout the day rhe line ends up on my eyelide.

  160. aschemers2009 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Prefer liquid liner, but this goes on pretty smooth

  161. Yadira2481 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love it

  162. wandamullinnix –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The best eyel

  163. deidra178 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love this eyeliner. It glides on smooth plus it waterproof!!!

  164. amy_aponte –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Glides on super smooth no tugging and just the right amount of shimmer

  165. ivannaje13 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    LOVE super dark goes in the inner corner so smooth and lasts all day

  166. MrsDBG –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    When you ONLY have black to choose from, what do you do? The brand is great, formula nice! Just need other colors. Blue, green, yellow… Red 🍒

  167. reesecarrie09 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It wore off not water proof

  168. mdre30831 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love black eyeliners

  169. awalker6197 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Eyeliner goes on smooth but after wearing it all day, I noticed it had transferred to my eyelids. I have hooded eyes so if you don’t, I would highly recommend!

  170. kara53 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I can always use a new black eyeliner. This one is good. I did my waterline and it did not run – which is always a bonus.

  171. fuszychick –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Glad to have a good, classic waterproof eyeliner. I find a good eyeliner plus mascara makes my eyes really pop, regardless of shadow, etc. This eyeliner is going on my “essential beauty products” list!

  172. nicholegjacobs07 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This GLIDES right on!!

  173. villegasmaria2454 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love it

  174. intuneamanda –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This eyeliner glides nicely

  175. Abbeysrun –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Wish it was blue or purple or green But black always comes in handy

  176. enedeski –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very smooth going on. Love how easy it is to apply!

  177. sarahgillmore –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love eyeliner

  178. beardswes41 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like liquid eyeliner better

  179. hdrost –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Smooth glide, nice rich color. Seems to be long lasting

  180. amber7528 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It’s so smooth, package so nicely and the color is beautiful

  181. ohsosweetie –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very black with a little shimmer. Glides easy on my waterline.

  182. jamie_mae_king –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The makeup bags are hidious at least 7/10 times. November’s especially

  183. lorihill579 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love it

  184. L_Rushing67_lr –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this just wish it was bigger

  185. Scatcat666 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Glides on so easily!

  186. misslobster26 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I really liked the shimmer and the soft tip of this pencil made it comfortable to apply even with very sensitive eyes, but it did not hold up under my “leaky eye” so i wouldn’t really call it waterproof…

  187. kassiekilgore426 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    it feels like nothing is on me and it doesn’t smudge

  188. emilylouisejohnson –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This goes on like a gel liner. Very smooth and effortlessly. It didn’t smear or fall under my eyes after wearing all day at work. Really like this liner.

  189. isaiahsmom2011 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not a dark black. I refer liquid eyeliner.

  190. l6128143255 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Really like the color and smoother application of this item, am not fond of the teeny tiny size of it though.

  191. shannon_layne1994 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love a black eyeliner and this one even had some glitter in it which for me was a bonus!!

  192. antiqueclutter –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not a fan of the glitter, and it smudged a bit, but it was def water proof!

  193. saraaguilar –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Wish it didn’t have shimmer

  194. emily_hulings65 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Obsessed with this liner! I’ve been really into black with glitter lately so I was so excited when I opened it. It lasts forever too! Also I love how prominent the sparkle is in the black.

  195. janeweitbrecht –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Wish for a finer point and not glittery

  196. guzzo_angela45 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love black it works well with my brown eyes.

  197. sarapgarcia1989 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This eye liner is smooth. It stays on all day. Only downside, my man and my lady are allergic to Jojoba. 🙁

  198. vidyanadar27 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I just love the shade, I got the pearl black and it had some glitters to it and it just stays long. Perfect for daily use.

  199. erieblvd93 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Was a little harder. But time will make it softer.

  200. sophy_holloman –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Glides on so smooth, like a ball point pen! Ugh I love it!!!

  201. veranda_begay –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice and smooth! Smudges perfect for Smokey look!

  202. naomifernandez808 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love love love this one, the sparkle is a nice touch and smooth.

  203. Jenny442 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I liked the color and it stayed on well.

  204. Evakull –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I prefer a liquid liner

  205. wyattterrell53 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love the shade!! I swear I wore this liner ALL DAY with no smudge after a few hours. It was the best I’ve used yet!

  206. MrsHarper84 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Pretty and easy to smear

  207. holly_l_reagan –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Perfect for travel with no smudging on eyelids. Great for hooded lids.

  208. Kimboslice7035 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice

  209. zena_bradhold –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice and smooth, stayed on without irritation

  210. ra3shine –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love eyeliners! Black is the best! And waterproof is so confident for traveling and other strenuous activities. Unfortunately my eyes are picky, and some waterproof liners are more prone to cause irritation. But so far, so good with this brand!

  211. g8torgirl83 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I really like this eyeliner! Definitely going to do gel liners from now on! It’s thick and more noticeable than regular pencil kinds, and lasts a lot longer.

  212. sramsey3777 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great eyeliner to use in your waterline. It doesn’t fade out since it is waterproof.

  213. annabonana0605 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Like it

  214. kmaher_rn –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not as waterproof in the waterline as my failsafes but I still love how easy it glides and lasts

  215. houseofhiggins –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love this! I’m not great at liquid eyeliner and this is nice and smooth to apply. Lasts well too!

  216. Beth-ann111213 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The color just makes your eyes pop

  217. DCoker3 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Also like browns

  218. aylajohnson04 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    pretty good eyeliner

  219. brandirizoli –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this! I want it in every color.

  220. brlewis5446 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love it

  221. Gracieet123 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Doesn’t go on too smooth

  222. hopemarks56 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Its ok

  223. jenniferteague79 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love this eyeliner, it’s great! This shade is perfect too!

  224. Nissyks418 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It was so small. I love the product but wished it was more than a tip full

  225. meandpen –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the sparkle

  226. tmbrearley –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I haven’t bought pencil liners in a long time as I find they always smudge even when waterproof so I’ve stuck to liquid for a long time. I’ll be excited to try out this formula and see how it wears.

  227. eliana_hempel –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Basic black pencil wanted to be able to tight line w it but it was a little too firm to comfortably do so

  228. amanda-jane- –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Super small unsure if there is more in it

  229. DivaVerde –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Stays put! Perfect size for travel

  230. sydney_acct_2017 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This color is amazing! It feels like velvet and doesn’t smudge when I rub my eye.

  231. emmure28 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Smooth application stays on all through the day would definitely buy a whole one

  232. youngmom –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love eye liner pencils the best. Easy to apply.

  233. nwomack002 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love receiving black eyeliners. Like this one because it is a bit different. It has some sparkles in it which is kind of cool. Enjoyed and will definitely use it again.

  234. michelle_dipalma –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love that this was waterproof!

  235. ashley_sosa91 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very black and blends the right amount without moving everywhere

  236. caponetto_cheri –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love to get eyeliners!

  237. Anergy –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Actually is waterproof! Love the sparkle.

  238. KellyV11 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like pencil liners that aren’t your average black at the moment. This one did not disappoint! Great for getting in/under the lashes for a subtle barely there color. The hint of shimmer is a nice touch even for someone getting close to 40. I didn’t ask for this but apparently Ipsy knew I would like it!

  239. holly_a_cookla –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I prefer these types of eyeliners and this one works well. Goes on smoothly. Stays put.

  240. PamelaHT –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Ok

  241. krystalannemiller56 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Went on great without heating and stayed on and looked great

  242. Melymaria02 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love it really pigmented 🙂

  243. Kymicjc –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Good product

  244. sydney420ashbourne –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love eyeliners that stay where they are suppose to.

  245. CassieRose1988 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love how easy and no messy it is! It can get to the waterline wonderfully without irritating the eye

  246. mictaylor8777 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Really easy to use

  247. gsargsyan559 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    i use this for my waterlinee

  248. tortaco –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Soft and long lasting!

  249. dshattraw –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is a beautiful eyeliner. The formula goes on so soft and smooth. Only wish it was in browns for color.

  250. barb_haines –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This glides on so nicely.

  251. sabrina20141999 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    ❤️

  252. ellischarlotte61 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It’s pretty good eye liner but I found myself having to reapply it through out the day

  253. lisapury –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I prefer color liners more so than black. The Smokey eye look isn’t me at all.

  254. JuliePeterson –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Only gave it a four star rating because it broke so I couldn’t keep using it.

  255. abwhite978 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love how easy it glides on

  256. orozcomarcia4 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Good.

  257. wickdslilscoogie702 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Works great

  258. Naila97 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Peut couler des fois

  259. ashleighrsmith –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the pearl shimmer, gives the eyeliner some pop!

  260. tiacia_13 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great!

  261. thisiskarlyn –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on smoothly and easily. Doesn’t smudge.

  262. magscheer13 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love how easy it glides on

  263. taylorrsmyth –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Liner

  264. alexiat39 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the eyeliners! Get a lot but they’re all so good!

  265. shelbylynch –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I don’t like pencil eyeliners so much

  266. ashley_belk_6 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I little thick

  267. katherinerijocarpio –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love all

  268. Claire_stevenson_clo –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It works well

  269. rileypandersen –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Loved this liner. It goes on really smoothly.

  270. trenna_p1021 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on very smoothly

  271. Hodgepodgelee –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This actually did what it says and was waterproof. Has pretty flecks of glitter in it.

  272. pamelahbic –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Really does stay.. waiting to see if it runs

  273. violetrium –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It was very creamy and smudge proof! Very pigmented! However there are l sparkles in it so if you don’t like that kinda thing don’t get it!

  274. cmkoschnick –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I really like it but I just don’t usually use this type of liner. Love the subtle shimmer though, would be pretty with darker makeup!

  275. ekonklin –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This liner goes on smooth and i really like it since it doesnt feel heavy too.

  276. aabbett2002 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Easy to apply but i have not tried to sharpen it yet.

  277. berenicecabrerasolis –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Its smudges really fast

  278. delshawndra –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great product just wish it was brown

  279. melanieurenawaffle –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very basic color

  280. maryannm0288 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very pigmented

  281. sammykatiesmith –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Again never used the brand so not sure and I don’t really use eyeliner but it’s always good to have it don’t want it every month though

  282. krystylestrada92 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Likes this product I don’t use eyeliner often but this one is pretty good

  283. mistic626 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not quite waterproof

  284. alexisahenryspam –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    A great black eyeliner for the waterline, doesnt smudge unless you want it to

  285. baileyoze5 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Good texture

  286. lexi_forshier –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the shade and shimmer- wish it had a fine tip.

  287. kortner1 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It is very dark and glides on well. it does not stay on the waterline though

  288. emily_mayhem –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the color and shimmer

  289. phoebepassmore04 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Just a little light on the black

  290. brust415 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very nice shade of black and lasts all day!

  291. Thiac –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Wow 🤩

  292. lharding1393 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    i like that it is not liquid

  293. rgadilhe –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Glides on super smooth. And did not smudge on my top lid.

  294. JakiB66 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I added this to my GB because it is a waterproof eyeliner, which is perfect for my summer swimming stash, and it has a pretty shimmer to it! My first time trying this brand, good quality!

  295. bparker042174 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love love love this pencil! It keeps the line well without feathering, and I can smudge it easily.

  296. allknowingfairy69 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the waterproof

  297. cdanilarn –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Normally glitter isnt for me but this one goes on like butter and soarkles just perfectly

  298. Kitsuquin –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on smooth

  299. hufford_macy58 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice eyeliner glides on nicely on the waterline

  300. melomene34 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Works as well as any other pencil liner, which is just okay.

  301. srfackler2 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love that it’s waterproof but I prefer to wear other eyeliner colors

  302. TonjaDanison –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It goes on ok but the color could be more bold. I find myself going over it with another eyeliner

  303. Licsious –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Don’t care for the shimmer of it but overall nice pencil

  304. zacharycollinsworth5 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Too spatkley for me but seems like it is made well

  305. mbartleson28 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Long lasting love it

  306. esperanzagonzalez098 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love it for my wing

  307. lisa_melendez86 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Stays in place

  308. paris_thurber –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Will more than likely get the full size product. Easily goes on, bold, beautiful, hqs a bit of a sparkle which makes it pop!

  309. dawnmorris139 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great for a pencil I prefer marker like tops

  310. melissaware28 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Loved it, it does work well for your waterline

  311. christina_uriarte –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very nice color!

  312. enyareoz97 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    goes on so smooth

  313. tobinbrandi90 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This doesn’t melt or smudge

  314. ahmontoya –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It glides on smooth and love the color and shimmer

  315. INDIGO-PSYCHE –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The colour is wonderful, but I still need some practice with eyeliners

  316. heidi47 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on easily and very smooth. Lasts well, perfect dark black shade.

  317. smn19012 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Glitter in eyeliner is bad

  318. emmajanesmommy –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the point on this pencil, nice and sharp!

  319. andrewsbrandy10 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this company!!

  320. skjudith –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love it

  321. kuddlebugg26 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Routine black liner. tiny bit of glitter in it. Lasted ok thru the day

  322. ssparks5599 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Can’t go wrong with a awesome liner

  323. Marissagil4 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    super pigmented

  324. maxxiehelmer2021 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    very blendable

  325. browdawn9097 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I just don’t like water proof to well hard for me to get off when I mess it up ! Lol

  326. alissa_corman –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great eyeliner. Stayed put all day.

  327. sara4haiti –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very silky and thin but will not layer well

  328. sailormaddie5678 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not big into pencil liners but this one was good

  329. thedreadedjewels –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love it! Easy and easy to come off

  330. audreybartok –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like the shade

  331. sevenbillionviews –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It was soft and easy to apply to my eyes.

  332. tkdjess22 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I need no more black eyeliner, but this one sticks around all day and looks amazing!!!

  333. marcydarcy0826 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I cant live without my eye liner

  334. chasitysmith051204 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Blackest of the black eye liner

  335. aszymkowiak87 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on smoothly and doesn’t cake up durning the day. Love this!

  336. sundas86 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great buy

  337. jasmineessex422 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Amazing coverage. The color is a little bit darker than I am used to but I’m growing to like it

  338. Nancy_Alexandria –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It literally does not come off 😉

  339. dcrossman –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Perfection!

  340. klabee –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Easy to dolly, great staying power and washes off fairly easily! I loved this product and hope to buy more in the future

  341. hbaker74ma98 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Been using this everyday really enjoying it

  342. Ts_tracyward –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It applies kinda thick which I don’t love. And it’s rather small for full size. Also don’t love that it’s difficult to sharpen.

  343. mgbohannon46 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    it’s perfect for under my eye and a little on top but isn’t great for a car eye or anything.

  344. sabrinayvonne_14 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the hint of glitter in the liner

  345. caseyc2014 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It has glitter in it, not a fan…

  346. kim83tr –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not the best

  347. tngirl112295 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It is a okay liner it smudges really easy though

  348. Sonja015_se –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I haven’t used it yet but my sister has and she loves how smooth it applies.

  349. shushannakocharyan –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I use brown eyeliners recently

  350. tabatha1316 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It’s not matte. Iam not a glittery person

  351. denissebarrios51 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Pinta Perfecto es el mejor de mi maquillaje

  352. shannon_snow –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love that it goes on smooth and stays all day!!

  353. nessymom –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This eyeliner is easy to use.

  354. Liv_lily –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like it, smooth application, nice pencil, but not so waterproof

  355. kj_mercer –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is not a shade that I would typically wear

  356. brouncem –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    i like the shade and it applies nicely and smoothly

  357. chrissyc_125 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    There is glitter. The eyeliner stays on quite well but starts to smudge after approximately 6-8 hours.

  358. tammy2006lpn –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I’m not crazy about pencil eyeliner but this one is better than most

  359. angieclark4 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on so smooth…. no dragging!

  360. ritagunn255 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice pencil eyeliner

  361. kayleighruth74 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Went on like velvet!

  362. daniellehwilliams321 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love it!! Great for a Smokey eyed look

  363. zoeller_barb –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The tube is hard to use. It is a good product once it’s on.

  364. freetempest1215 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Doesn’t glide on well.

  365. kylierice800 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It’s very smooth and goes on easy

  366. beccasmom63 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Smooth

  367. jodiferg45 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the sparkle in the liner

  368. autumn423555 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I don’t really use pencil eyeliners as much as I do liquid. I would rather have a liquid eyeliner like the one I got from eyeko.

  369. darkcrimsongothella –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great eyeliner give me more

  370. clairepois –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Didn’t smudge but just ok. I dont prefer stick eyeliner, and tip is wide for me.

  371. zoegodfroy54 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Really dark and draws on smoothly.

  372. rlesouthern –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This stayed on well. Would recommend.

  373. Lb062210 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love! Stays on great

  374. Jewel2008 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this kind

  375. mr_snazzy_taco –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great product! Went on smoothly, great color too, lasts all day

  376. harkinsaurelia –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like it. But I use it for my bottom eyeliner and it never really stays.

  377. naysig58 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The perfect choice for a Smokey eye or grunge smudge. Very versatile and easy to use. It doesn’t leave a next day stain either

  378. maddiem211 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    amazing 10/10 recommend

  379. pac27posies –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very beautiful. I haven’t had an eyeliner in a while. It’s the season for Yes! eyeliner! & being extra pretty.. maybe times of extra makeup and color. Thank you.

  380. beadle89 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Prefer a little lighter but love the rest the nice smooth application feels really easy and nice

  381. jstanley15 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great eyeliner

  382. Superbunnie0924 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very smooth on application and the small size fits perfectly in my small bag. Definitely would recommend. The only thing that I was disappointed about is after about an hour it would leave a dark area under my eyes.

  383. Violinist1493 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very nice

  384. 244854 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    it lasted way longer then my other eyelines i own

  385. Taanesshha –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the shade but I don’t find it goes on to well.

  386. sjwells23 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Gorgeous eyeliner love the color!

  387. tom360moden04 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Beat one I’ve ever owned

  388. mari4u2envy –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the black pearl color!

  389. laicilou –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not usually a huge fan of pencil liners but this was awesome! Super waterproof, but tough to work with over eyeshadow.

  390. ndettmering15 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Went on smooth. Didn’t smudge

  391. Nikki_543 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like my eyeliners obsidian like so black black is no longer relevant but it was OK, and it looks alot smoother in the Pic than it actually is, thought it would glide but had to apply a bit more pressure than planned but all in all great

  392. jdenisesmith38 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I didn’t like the glitter in it

  393. cokerstrong4618 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is awesome! Stays all in place all day!

  394. yllseg –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Waterproof, perfect formula it does not smudge and stays on all day!

  395. pkeefe175 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I was hoping for something other than black but you know I guess black is what they send but you know I would hope they would match it with your eyes

  396. dguzman0313 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Liked that it did not smudge

  397. ashleebeavers926 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice color and easy to use.

  398. karlahernandez504 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Would have given it a 5 but the liner does smudge and is not waterproof. The formula is definitely more creamy I like to use for smoky eye instead

  399. claraelena2607 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love this eyeliner it is so pretty and I didn’t realize until I put it on that there was glitter in it!!

  400. sammypoo_lynn –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Finally found an eyeliner that stays pretty well on the waterline

  401. klsully312 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very smooth

  402. rgilsdorf2016 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Long lasting, not a brand I’ve used before, and it didn’t irritate my sensitive skin

  403. karameloy –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love this shade

  404. wats754 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Eyeliner works fine! I really didn’t need any more black pencil liners, though.

  405. madstaylorbell –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    More of a liquid eyeliner fan but this product is nice!

  406. autumnshatzert1 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    it was really nice to appy an really pigmented

  407. david5080 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Went on smooth the color was very pigmented but it did smudge a lot which was a bit disappointed for a smudge proof waterproof eyeliner

  408. chelseevalentine –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love the shade last all day😁

  409. pjandbuzz –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love!!

  410. cathrinedmarie –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Good

  411. flgtr24 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on smooth and lasts all day!

  412. kara_lindemon –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I don’t really use eyeliner pencils, I prefer a gel liner for a finer wing but this is a decent quality for what it is

  413. tweetynails1 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This eyeliner was really easy to use. The shade was perfect, it didn’t smudge when wet. I loved it.

  414. sara_worthey –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on smooth, easy to apply. Love the black shimmer “pearl” color of this eyeliner!

  415. mchristine2206 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The color is solid and it definitely doesn’t run

  416. amclain89 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great pencil

  417. punchysprincess –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is easy to apply. Smooth and love the small size that is perfect for my small purse sized touch up bag.

  418. chelseamarilyn –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Like that its waterproof, not a fan of the shimmer.

  419. ang0904 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice love is waterproof.

  420. Crystalcurnew2 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great shade..so smooth and easy to apply.. great look?

  421. suewagner24 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love how easily it glides on.

  422. emma_fay_9 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Was surprised to find that it had glitter, but when it’s watched it was really pretty I haven’t heard of the occasion to use it yet

  423. smeghan84 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is perfect eyeliner goes on smooth and I mean really smooth and lasts all day long ! It’s something I might look into purchasing for sure

  424. Inappropriatemo_mmy2 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love the color 😍

  425. xgabyramirezx –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this for waterline

  426. mrs_sciotto –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Definitely not waterproof but still great! Smears..

  427. ronda311979 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    So smooth. It just glided on. It’s prefect. Lasted all day and night till I washed it off. No black eye look at all.

  428. angelaspears1970 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    soo much pigment

  429. kvs9262000 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Sparkly black. Love the texture and pigment!

  430. kayla_desouza17 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great pigmented black eye liner

  431. naomike88 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is a GREAT waterproof eyeliner and as a pencil it’s outstanding!!! I just can’t seem to locate a place to purchase a full size?!?

  432. kellyalexis2004 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very pigmented and stay in the waterline. Also doesn’t irritate my eyes at all

  433. lovelucklife –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I didnt expect this to have a little glitter in it. Not to much though. It looks great. Other than that its pretty much what you’d expect from a pencil liner. It did seem to stay a little better than I’m used to though.

  434. crazyrainbowfrog –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Sometimes the sparkles/shimmer gets into my eyes and makes it hard to see, but this is the first pencil eyeliner I’ve tried that doesn’t give me raccoon eyes !

  435. jesseddy123 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Cute but wasn’t expecting the sparkles

  436. proudmommy2615 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on so smooths looks great

  437. keelin_fuentes3 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    its sparkly- not for me but it was at least good qaulity

  438. ddenney18 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love a long lasting, no smudge, liner

  439. westbrookm48 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This eyeliner goes on nice and smooth and stays on all day.

  440. Lukymama –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice

  441. Chapow99 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not a fan of pencil eyeliners

  442. -devilicious- –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is absolutely PERFECT for my lower lids and i couldn’t love it more!!

  443. angella_varady5 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Would’ve been nice to receive sample that was a bit bigger and easier to hold, however due to it’s size it is a perfect one for on the go

  444. kristycox286 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The eye liner went on so smooth and looked great !!

  445. Gigi-McCain –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love getting waterproof gel eyeliner

  446. angelinabrito2000 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love it, it glides easily and has a little glitter as well.

  447. Sweets429 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Pretty eyeliner

  448. yvargasvega –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It was good

  449. brangoller –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Did ot care for the glitter in it.

  450. paxsammy_1994 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love the color, I’m more of a liquid eyeliner girl but this was great as well!

  451. haileykirou –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It’s very smooth but has dark blue sparkles in it??

  452. SuzeeHigdon –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Smoothly glides on

  453. Ldrover35 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love eye liner in black and that’s what I got so no complaints. It works like an eye liner. Nothing fancy but no problems either.

  454. chels61025 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love pencil liners!

  455. Andiigirl1 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This really is waterproof!!! I’d like to see more of this brand!

  456. omegagossett –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I’m just more a fan of liquid eyeliner but this was easy to use and awesome shade!!!

  457. crissyfolks –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very nice

  458. thompsondawn1976 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The little sparkle this has makes my eyes pop in color

  459. gr8ful_pkap –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love eye liner and black is my go to but i dont ever use waterproof eyeliner because it is a pain to get off and completely unnecessary for me. Probably wont use the rest of this.

  460. Holly815 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice formula goes on well has decent staying power but the glittery “pearl” shade was not for me.

  461. mrsbastin –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    went on smooth and kept pigment

  462. mamasoldier –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on very easily and is very black. Really like this eyeliner.

  463. ladybug40906 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Thanks!

  464. Bcohn1985 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is my new favorite eyeliner

  465. abbeynormal99 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not a very smooth formula to draw on. A nice sparkly black. Fun, but not my first pick for eyeliners.

  466. scarletfreak1294 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Last longer than mu other eyeliner

  467. bethanylinhares –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    it came broken 🙁

  468. lozano80_melissa –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I prefer liquid eyeliner so this review is not really relevant.

  469. magedi10497 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Loved it

  470. bayleechavez –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice pencil, bold color!

  471. nancy_l_duplessis –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Wonderful pencil

  472. pansdaughter –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I am super picky with eyeliner. I wear it daily and I work retail, so I can can break a sweat no matter what time of year. Waterproof eyeliner is a must and this one checks the boxes. The glitter I could do without, but it does not detract from the liner.

  473. sweetleaf81 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Too many sparkles

  474. myfivedoctors –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Like liquid eyeliner more

  475. Nataliakey –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice black eyeliner

  476. kdsattre –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    One of my favorite brands!

  477. tigers_ohmy –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Stayed on all day on my waterline which has been so hard to find for me! Absolutely in love

  478. IzzRam16 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I actually really liked this liner for my upper inner water line. Held up great

  479. Mikayle –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    easy application and very pigmented

  480. Mizelleolivia –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    New favorite!

  481. kbull0757 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    good black, goes on smoothly

  482. Cheyannejones81 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Went on dark,stays on most of the day

  483. kia_autry –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    No sparkle in eyeliner.

  484. laurenmalvarez1987 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the color, goes on smoothly

  485. atibbs22 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It’s good

  486. haleykirtland23 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    didn’t realize it was glittery but i like it. i prefer liquid though

  487. danesiathornton –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice pencil but I’m so used to liquid eyeliners.

  488. rissakj09 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Smeared a little on bottom lash line but definitely want to purchase a full size

  489. cebalutski –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This pencil is awesome. Lasted me a whole day of Black Friday festivities. Glides on smooth and easy to remove mess ups.

  490. annoramya_22 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice gliding pencil. Layer several coats for desired darkness. Smudges nicely so recommend for that look

  491. juliatownsend808 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Brown eyeliner?

  492. oliverosgaby33 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like this eyeliner

  493. teko86teko –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    too thick

  494. katietuffin97 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Pencil was broken

  495. janicehardy1966 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love!

  496. tinallado –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    New fav

  497. junior1972_jc –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It goes on easy and gives room to expand

  498. parisce1998 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Havent received it yet Just getting my points

  499. twillaglee –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love it

  500. karmakittyhasclaws –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It tends to blur under the eye shortly after putting it on so not good for clean look

  501. n4thelongrun –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The cap broke before I could use it

  502. alliehodous –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I don’t wear eye liner a bunch but since I got this I tried it and havnt gone a day without it now

  503. jenabrams77 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Does not stay in the waterline

  504. havenmnorris –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    cute

  505. cindy_main80 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    A little disappointed because I received mine and the whole tip was broken off so I never got a chance to test it out

  506. jamie_neely –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Like the black but not the glitter

  507. shadowsoultarot –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Glides on smooth and stays in place.

  508. vive9831234 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Sparkles?

  509. barnes18630 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Went on really light

  510. 5kingstoomany –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Best eyeliner ever usef

  511. philmon_mallory –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I personally won’t wear black eyeliner.

  512. bonniecastle222 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    smudges

  513. jaybride320 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    not a fan of eyeliners but this is cute

  514. iluvyoux3hae –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Creamy, long lasting, love this liner

  515. jjbracewell00 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Was not expecting the glitter in it and not a fan of how much more work it takes to get the glitter all off

  516. Darbaby000 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice product, just sick of getting eyeliners

  517. nlvinson2003 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Creamy and smooth on the eyes

  518. purple_turtles1221 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It lasts all day long and doesn’t smudge.

  519. cbyone –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I was excited to try this eyeliner but unfortunately it’s not waterproof.

  520. bassline_2019 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love that shade just not for me personally. But I’m going to try it out!

  521. CollsW –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It is really creamy and easy to apply. It lasts all day, which is fabulous. I prefer a matte colour over a shimmer, but it is still pretty.

  522. hlegg01 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I don’t normally like pencil liner, but this goes on really smoothly.

  523. aguoncora –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It’s a good brand.

  524. hairstyle2591 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love the color and buttery consistency.

  525. LadyDipsy –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Black is my favorite color so when I see pearl black 🖤 yasss it goes on well and doesn’t smear too much I love these kind of liners

  526. kristy_hudson29 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It’s ok. Doesn’t blend well so unless you like a much thicker look also gave a cracked look with eye shadow

  527. emilyflorczak93 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is a fine crayon liner. It smudges easily, and I found it bled at the crow of my eyes as the day went on. Personally I like liquid eyeliner more!

  528. 12redpines –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Waterproof is the only way i can wear eyeliner without looking like a raccoon an hour later. This liner goes on smooth, and stays put until I take it off.

  529. rlmcleod2010 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Dod the job

  530. beckywolf40_bw –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Doesn’t smudge

  531. romanowski_kelly –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    A nice basic black eyeliner with a little sparkle. Does what you need it to do.

  532. pappask_146197 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice and smudge proof once it dries

  533. aliciakaja –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    like the shade of it

  534. jaclynyvette_tx –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the surprise sparkle!

  535. eddiesmonkeyprincess –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It was a very nice little eyeliner!

  536. knighthg3413 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love this eyeliner.

  537. nnysee –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Truly a waterproof eyeliner.

  538. ella12843 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love how dark it is but I’m not a huge fan of pencils

  539. taynaboettcher11 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    great pencil with super easily application ; but it does smear/transfer sorta easier than i’d like. but i love the texture of the pencil and all

  540. trislergirl11 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Seams a bit light for myb liking shade wise. Application and ware are amazing tho

  541. t97rebel –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like black, ut I would love some brown!!!!!

  542. jgrecia24 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Perfect Shade Will definitely be buying when it runs out…Which will be Soon

  543. kristenb198091 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love this liner

  544. selinadamico9 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It stays on all day and night. The quality is great definitely worth a shot

  545. kara11305 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Finally a freaking pencil liner thank you ipsy for finally getting it right no more liquid keep it up

  546. trishmcleod9404 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love it

  547. jmtheroux –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love eyeliners

  548. esmith32 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on very smoothly!

  549. Rebeccasommers80 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love color and it stays on all day

  550. sarahlsilvernail –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This worked great as a tightliner. It didn’t smudge, or give me raccoon eyes, and it applied smoothly and evenly. I will purchase this.

  551. robbiecarlton7 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not waterproof and it’s alright

  552. shanna_farrell88 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Literally the easiest eye pencil ive ever used. Super smooth application

  553. melrdh0501 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Please send other colors

  554. AshleySpar –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is one of the best eye liners I’ve used!

  555. suehay1012 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the product so much………………….

  556. tsanders_081478 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I needed a black eyeliner like this one. It’s perfect, thank you!

  557. amber_douglas422 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I wish it would have come in dark brown since I am not a huge fan of black eyeliner. But it glides on smoothly and stays all day.

  558. latayacathey –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The best eyeliner I ever used

  559. Aganer342 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Was not as impressed with this eyeliner when you put it on it felt like there was grittiness to it.

  560. kellismith123075 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on so smooth and I am not having any smudging problems like with my old eyeliner.

  561. heartdoxie03 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Only complaint is the eyeliner doesn’t last that long. You have to reapply a lot thru out the day

  562. Motormom2013 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Liner is better than any i have used

  563. valentinaroserochang –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very smooth, shade has a little bit of shimmer but its really cute

  564. kaylagrace1773 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I really love this but it broke on me

  565. nicholesmith29619 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This eyeliner is one of the best! Has good pigment and it goes on smoothly. The color is great and comes off easy.

  566. emilyirenedrew –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love it

  567. LOCA419 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this eyeliner. It stays put and doesn’t rub onto my hooded lids.

  568. dao_dian –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Small

  569. ascenciomonique3 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It’s a good color

  570. chantenesabrina –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Can’t go without eyeliner. This one is nice.

  571. chrebenyak-rodriguez –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like this, but I wish IPSY would send out navy blue eyeliner just to change things up without going wild!

  572. K9nJaime –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Broken when I received it but I love the black with sparkles. Was able to use it once, it went on smoothly.

  573. salynapatterson –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very smooth application!

  574. aevans0193 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It works

  575. rachel_leia_hughes –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Works okay it’s water proof but kinda smudgy.

  576. ivygodyss –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    LOVE this eye liner. It goes on easy, whether a thin or thick line and the glitter is a nice touch. Not too much/glittery… it was a very nice surprise.

  577. ccrispi_77 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love eyeliners and love that this one goes on so smoothly and is waterproof

  578. flyygirl_2003 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Smears a little bit goes on smooth

  579. joannie0502 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This shade is amazing

  580. erinkitt999 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not big on sparkles

  581. kaylarainashby –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love a good water line eyeliner. I’ve been needing one this will definitely come in handy!

  582. LisaTagal –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Easy application and super smooth

  583. jessicahmonique –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Pretty basic

  584. janethgabriela –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    kind of gets all over my eye but i still like it

  585. vlkaiser9 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice color, felt natural woth my dark eyelashes. Goes on really smoothly, comes with a nicely shaped point – not too sharp, which hasn’t mashed much in a couple uses. Will be interesting to see how it holds up / sharpens.0

  586. kristenlewis334 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great product!

  587. graceanderson144 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love

  588. 1GIRL2FACES –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very smooth and pigmented.

  589. Katleone71 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Glides on smoothly.

  590. khlmoore84 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice inky color. Glides on.

  591. somebodysomeone421 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I always use very black eyeliner and I’ve never used this brand before but I love it! Goes on so smooth and very dark and stays put really well. I like it so much!

  592. sljst191 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I hate pencil liners

  593. candichick86 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Was ok, not the bomb .com but it’s doable.

  594. jane_ashley –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Awesome consistency

  595. baglady2727 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very nice and smooth.

  596. dorcaswade –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Could stay on longer

  597. lilfoxdee –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like browns better.

  598. wattj1018 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Only problem i have is you cant sharpen it

  599. reb_oneill1996 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the shimmer of this eyeliner. Gave it four stars because doesn’t go on as dark as I expected.

  600. photochic35mm –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I’ve been through many eye liner pencils but this goes on smoother than any other for an amazing finish!

  601. adriana_marquez1123 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Long lasting but would prefer no shimmer.

  602. bridgetteawesome10 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice shade smooth glide

  603. gabbilove7 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Works good

  604. hnilges28 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This product went on smooth and is great for an eyeliner newbie.

  605. mallorykmcgee –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not as waterproof as I would’ve hoped. I still got a decent amount of smearing.

  606. dpinales –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I really like this eyeliner it goes on smooth and it’s a nice color.

  607. dianapatriciaveraper –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great color love it

  608. gracekate467 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the formula good for smoky eye

  609. saraviayasmin –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Loved this eyeliner stays on for a long time.

  610. browneyez35 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great liner that stays put.

  611. dani1268 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not extremely smooth when applying, and not waterproof. But highly pigmented.

  612. appleangelgirl –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    excited to try it! love black eyeliner

  613. jillmarie2205 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This goes on smooth, wears well, and I didn’t have an issue with smudging or smearing

  614. Phyn91 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The freaking best!

  615. lillybryant2013 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I absolutely love it!!

  616. katemyers906 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Wasn’t dark enough

  617. kimb8s –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on smoothly for mature eyes

  618. tattianna_austin –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The shimmer is so pretty

  619. hanaherr22 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Loved the glitter in this eyeliner! It goes on smooth as well.

  620. rockymist97 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love the shimmer in this eyeliner, but it was extremely difficult to remove at the end of the day.

  621. Mrs725 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I actually like this eyeliner. But I love eyeliners. It does tug a little when I apply it. But it last all day and does not smudge for me.

  622. rgeier2020 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    very small. the formula is cakey.

  623. gavagan_ruby –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The tip is very thick so if that’s what you want then great! I like fine point eyeliners so this isn’t my favorite. On the bright side, the thick tip allows for a bold look and is good for smoking out your waterline/under eye

  624. Taylor_A_Lewis –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is pretty nice. I haven’t worn it out yet, but it is defiantly waterproof. I tested it on my hand and after 15 min I tried to take it off. I tried everything I could think of and it just didn’t come off. I prefer liquid liners but this is pretty nice.

  625. trix68 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This goes on nice. Stays on. Has glitter in it, not for me. Biggest issue I have with this is that my pencil did not feed out more when turned, so the sample was only what was visible, a very small amount.

  626. KayMog –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This lasts all day and doesn’t smudge! Love it

  627. cgal_06 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Nice eyeliner.

  628. cpolazkowyj –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I absolutely love the pigment on this. It goes on smoothly and lasted all day long

  629. marcelapass –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Good staying power

  630. Aspagnolo07 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Works really good. Just didn’t last me very long.

  631. cslenker –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This just didn’t last very long

  632. HMHolbrook –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I prefer liquid eyeliner, and find it easier to apply, but this one did go on smoothly, blended nicely and has a bit of shimmer in the color if you like that.

  633. maggiedmcdonald –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on nice and smooth, love the pigment and it lasts!

  634. lerogers529 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This worked well. It isn’t completely waterproof. I wore this for a while and after getting in the rain and rubbing my eyes for a bit it smudged quickly. So water resistant and smudge resistant just not at the same time.

  635. nikiszabo74 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Beautiful color. Didn’t smudge at all!

  636. agayeva_kheyat –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Good onee

  637. danibwins –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Smooth liner

  638. yvonnevoorhees_sadp –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Classic!

  639. perladstrickx –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Good quality and good for travel

  640. Julieox –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This eyeliner goes on so smooth & stays without smudges all day

  641. eunicetrowsdale_et –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Makes my eyes look great

  642. jessicabikales –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    shade was perfect, eyeliner went on smooth

  643. weese_tara –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Absolutely love the color nice and dark didn’t run only down fall is it’s hard to remove

  644. Jayme_Lyn_Taylor –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love eyeliners would rather like to see more color than just black though.

  645. cyd1996 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I wore this for Thanksgiving and it glided only my waterline so smoothly

  646. zeniabubbles –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Its really good. Not dry

  647. Lovesag –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love the shimmer! A little lighter black but still like it

  648. cpg76 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I have sensitive , watery eyes, so I need mascara that states it for contact wearers, or sensitive eyes. I would love to try the Thrive Liquid Lash extensions . But my go to for years is, Lancomé Defenicils., The thin brush is spectacular, and I can grab every lash , with no eye irritation.

  649. bobbileykam –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Absolutely my favorite eyeliner ever. I love pencil eyeliners and effect they have when slightly smudged. I love the waterproof quality and how it keeps the smoky effect from smearing after application. The lighter black shade and shimmer make it perfect for day or night. Will definitely become a staple in my makeup case.

  650. christinabuxton –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Best ever high recamend

  651. Restlesslittlething –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Made my eyes water, but I love trying new eyeliners!

  652. PamelaBrown –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This liner goes on smoothly with no tugging or pulling, but the staying power is in question. I do use several hydrating products around my eyelid area but could interfere with its waterproof abilities. More experience is needed for a fair review.

  653. kdr819 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Like this – just hard for me to get a point so I can apply a fine line

  654. LisaSpc89 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is only a “point” sticking out the end of a tube! How am I supposed to know if I like something I can only use 2 times?

  655. jessicapainter8927 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Goes on SO smooth. It’s like butter!! P

  656. bellbee2 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like this bit the glitter in it irritating my eyes

  657. memeevans1971 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This is a very good, and fun eyeliner. I have the pearl black and it’s not too strong with the pearl effect, but every once in awhile you get this very pretty subtle sparkle/pearly shine. It stays on all day and comes off easy. I will be purchasing this!

  658. silvakatherine710 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Really makes the green in my eyes pop when I use it on my water line.

  659. cosmicrys –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this product for my waterline, it adds a bit of depth to any makeup look. It’s so easy to apply as it’s very pigmented!

  660. Dmboychuk –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Excellent pencil

  661. chocochipkookie_1800 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Went on pretty smoothly! I normally don’t like pencil eyeliners, but this one was pretty good. It lasted all day and didn’t smudge

  662. allieanstey –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love it! Goes on smooth and stays on all day long. No smudging either

  663. holly41051 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Perfect eyeliner.

  664. lindahines –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    This was a great find. Smooth application.

  665. mlhaley19 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I never wear eyeliner because its a pain, but this went on smooth and was pretty easy to make good lines. Didn’t smudge either! Water proof is a must!

  666. wendi_wang –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Easy to use

  667. meganberkes –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It smuged a little after application.

  668. me2539 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I don’t know if I can sharpen this but it blends and smudges well.

  669. 1024_mkh –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Works well nice bold liner

  670. Huskymama –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The color was great and it went on the back of my hand super easy and smooth. However, I do not wear eyeliner so into the trash it goes.

  671. WhoKilledLauraPalmer –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this! It glides on and stays put.

  672. brybry_047 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like to use liners like this to tight line my eyes for that extra pop, but this liner kind of smeared off into my waterline after a few minutes of application. I’m not sure what I did wrong but this rarely happens to me.

  673. livilovey –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    found my new favorite eyeliner! i wear on my waterline and it stays on all day long without fading or smudging

  674. annmarie_oxox –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love black eyeliner, did not expect the glitter

  675. jadreamllc –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I love a dark black for eyeliner like the darkest black i can find. This is it. Im not too fond of using pencil on my eye because im too lazy to sharpen it, but you know.. its actually really smooth. I wont go out my way to get it myself but its nice that they sent it and I’ll definitely be using it.

  676. zflokich –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Good solid eyeliner

  677. kcbear0208 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Very much waterproof! Loved it!

  678. PittieGurl –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Like that it was waterproof, great for the waterline. Just hope I don’t get a black eyeliner every other month

  679. shoelover740 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Soft and glides on nice. Not necessarily waterproof bc i could rub it right off

  680. denisepoveda20 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    The shade of this liner was shimmery and I don’t know if that’s what I was looking for

  681. ignaciadno –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    ok product

  682. kfox19 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I use liquid eyeliner

  683. marluz081 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Me encanta que no se corrre dura todo el dia esperf3cto sin duda lo comprare

  684. jeffersonj4 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Its very dark which is nice but just not the eyeliner i would ever reach for

  685. kellyhull8 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Went on smoothly but didn’t stay put. I prefer my usual liner. I also prefer a brown liner.

  686. isabellamarie1324 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    looks really good on my eyes

  687. koukla2014 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this

  688. dragonflygirl2004 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    love it

  689. blegashmeh –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Good but might be allergic to it. It made my eyes swell up.

  690. linzcumming –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Don’t use if you are looking for anything other than a smudgy line or to smudge, not a fan

  691. ran9642 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It wears off me too soon it doesn’t stay as well as my Smashbox liner

  692. andcreated –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    You know how sometimes waterproof pencils still smudge after you apply them? This one does not. It goes where you place it and doesn’t budge all day. Even tried it swimming and was pleasantly suprised from a pencil.

  693. maclee8789 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Broke on first time using it

  694. ericafransen69 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Perfect

  695. svhopkins –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Perfect pencil liner for a smokey eye!

  696. pcuervo710 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Took think for regular liner but did use it a little to create a smoky look

  697. ksbarefield26 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this eyeliner better than any other eye liner I’ve ever used.

  698. thanisa_perez –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    went on easily, stayed on and no smudge…loved it

  699. tis4trishee –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    It had some sparkle, so it feels more date-night than everyday to me. But it went on smoothly without being too soft or too dry, which I like. It ran off my water line a bit, which I didn’t expect with a waterproof formula

  700. r41nb0w_br1t3 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Love this liner..glides on smooth

  701. jr_birdsell1978 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like how smooth it went on.

  702. lacynicole_45556 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Applying it was super easy.

  703. MsAfinow –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    I like waterproof!!

  704. a_hawkinson –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Not as dark as I’d like and I don’t care for the little glitter pieces but it is definitely smudge proof

  705. KastineC –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Really pretty! Glides on creamy with sparkles!

  706. jchardonnay –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Great waterproof eyeliner love it doesn’t smudge or smear perfect for a night out

  707. beelee02 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Usually I like liquid eyeliner, but this one is waterproof, which I like!

  708. mkoenig991 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Smooth pencil. Not as dark of a black as I would like it but overall application was smooth

  709. mnguyen0005 –

    Reviewed by IPSY

    Loved this eyeliner! Used it on my lower lash line and this is one of the first pencils/crayon that i have used that did not smear.

  710. Jennifer Davis –

    Best ever

  711. Griselda Mayorga (verified owner) –

    I love it

  712. Jill B. (verified owner) –

    Great product! I’ve tried loads of eyeliners which have been very expensive but this is by far the best with no smudging and great price

  713. Stephanie C. (verified owner) –

    Love the wear on this liner

  714. June L. (verified owner) –

    Perfect color. Timely arrival. Thanks!

  715. Destiny Galloway (verified owner) –

    I absolutely love this product. I don’t think I’ve ever used an eyeliner that has went on that smooth and deep and no run off and lasts a long time. Which is why I had to go buy one of each. Thank you again

  716. Tina (verified owner) –

    I absolutely LOVE the pearl black eye liner! I first received it in my Ipsy bag and fell in love. It’s my new favorite and won’t use any other liner now! It stays on my water line all day at work and doesn’t budge AT ALL! I highly recommend!

  717. Laura Wilson (verified owner) –

    Best eyeliner I’ve found! What a great price! Loved the special gifts included with my purchase!

  718. Mary Kay Victor (verified owner) –

    I like the pearl and it stays in place

  719. Tammy Hughes (verified owner) –

    I Love it! Lasts ALL day!

  720. Kimberly A. (verified owner) –

    Love this eyeliner, it’s so smooth and lasts through swimming and showering. It truly is waterproof.

  721. Kim Davis –

    I love this eyeliner! It glides on perfect and lasts pretty much the whole day! Definitely recommend it and it’s worth the cost! My daughter must love it too, because it always goes missing and ends up in her make up bag lol

  722. Dana Allen (verified owner) –

    Love this product..

  723. Malissa (verified owner) –

    I love this eyeliner! It’s looks great. Lasts all day! I’m really sensitive to makeup and haven’t had any issues. Will order again! I highly recommend

  724. Anonymous (verified owner) –

    I haven’t tried this yet but I’m sure it’s good because all the products I have ordered have been good.

  725. Neermiss –

    I originally got this eyeliner in a subscription bag. Fell in love with it the first time I used it. So glad I was able to find it on Amazon. Goes on smooth, stays on, doesn’t smudge, and I tend to rub my eyes a little during the day. This liner has a little bit of sparkle, I love that! Most importantly it isn’t difficult to remove.

  726. Amazon Customer –

    A friend recommended this eyeliner to me years ago and I absolutely love it! I never have to touch it up throughout my workday, doesn’t sweat off and glides on perfectly every time. Great product.

  727. amber –

    This is the best eyeliner I have found. It goes on easily and stays put. So happy to have found this!!

  728. Betsy –

    I have never been able to use a pencil for eyeliner.. always used liquid.Got this as a gift and was amazed at how easy it glided on!Purchased more on Amazon!

  729. angelina –

    This eyeliner is the best I’ve tried so far. It is pure waterproof and does not smudge run or move. The sparkle is great doesn’t affect wear. This is really a true water resistant eyeliner. And true smudgeproof. I will be buying more. I love this. 5stars long wearing also. Tried a sample size and day after bought full size

  730. SuzyQ –

    This eyeliner stays on all day long! Love it!!

  731. Jeannie –

    Goes on smoothly and does not require a sharpener.

  732. Sharon G. –

    Great color made my blue eyes stand out.

  733. Kelly Highfield (verified owner) –

    Favorite eyeliner ever!!!

  734. Regina Kemp (verified owner) –

    Love this eyeliner

  735. Jess –

    I order this because Amazon was the only place I could find it after I received one from IPSY. But it’s not the same. This one is self-sharpening, versus the manual sharpening one and applies differently.

  736. Anonymous (verified owner) –

    I feel like the company changed their recipe(?) for this product. It does not stay on al long as it used to, and and definitely smudges. But, still better than most products out there.

  737. Dana Allen (verified owner) –

    I love this eye liner…

  738. Avid Reader –

    I got a sample from ipsy, honestly the only product I liked from them so I cancelled but wanted the full size of this eyeliner. Goes on nice, easy to blend when first applied but then stays in place and does not fade throughout the day.

  739. Tara W. (verified owner) –

    I absolutely love this eyeliner! I received one in my Ipsy bag about a year ago and it finally came to the very end of the pencil. So I order another one ASSP! It’s long lasting and goes on smoothly. Compared to other high-end eyeliners I’ve used, this is by far the best! On top of that, shipping was exceptionally fast and I had a couple surprise gifts with my order.

  740. Debra H. (verified owner) –

    Best eyeliner on the market!!! Thank you so much!

  741. Heather M. (verified owner) –

    I’ve been thru dozens of eyeliner brands, and this has been my favorite! It’s easy to apply, and stays put. I love that it doesn’t end up running into the inner corners of my eyes..yuck. Great product at a good price. Thank you!!

  742. Julie G. –

    Love this eyeliner!!!

  743. Erin L. –

    Best eyeliner ever!! My go to eyeliner for everything and all the colors rock!! Goes on smooth and does not wear off! Hooked on L.O.C.K. !!!

  744. Erin L. –

    Love the burgundy more than I thought I would! Absolutely in love with eyeliner, goes on smooth, no sharpening and stays put all day!

  745. Rachele My Belle –

    I bought this is in pearl khaki, at first in the tube it struck me as a deeper green, but happily for me it is more of a greenish-charcoal color, if that makes sense (okay, it really doesn’t, but I can say with certainty that this is the color you want if you’re thinking black but don’t want harsh kohl around your eyes like some Theda Bara wannabe from the 1920s, so this was better for me. The pencil itself is really smooth and goes on creamy enough to blend it out, it’s water resistant and just really nice, it’s my new favorite eyeliner.

  746. Gina Gilbert –

    Love this eye liner however black is never available for purchase

  747. Leanne Fort –

    I love the Pearl Black eyeliner. When will it be back in stock? I usually buy several at a time.

  748. Jennifer C. –

    Quick shipping!

  749. lana –

    I love this eyeliner!! looks good to me

  750. lana –

    I love this eyeliner!! It’s good on me

  751. Katie S. –

    this is the only eyeliner I have found that doesn’t irritate my eyes. it’s also beautiful!!

  752. Amee S. –

    I love the L.O.C.K It waterproof eyeliner. It is my favorite. I have it in black and brown!

  753. Gina –

    Love it! Want to the waterproof black also however you are out of that.

  754. Anonymous –

    Love this eyeliner! Stays on nice doesn’t bleed.

  755. Lishia T. –

    I finally found an eyeliner that goes on well, stays on all day (and I work in a humid environment) and comes off easy at night with makeup remover. The gel formula is really nice!

  756. Jewel –

    Love, love, love this eyeliner!

  757. Jayme –

    These eyeliners are the best. Nice glide for application. The color stays on. My favorite is the pearl brown.

  758. Christine N. –

    Perfect color with just a touch of sparkle. Very long lasting. Great quality for a great price

  759. Brenda Bainbridge –

    Luv it

  760. Adrienne H. –

    Love this color

  761. Colleen Bricker –

    Love this eyeliner. Stays on all day long.

  762. Anonymous –

    Love it!

  763. Awna –

    Super quick delivery! Love this eyeliner!!

  764. Lori G. –

    Price was great and received my order very fast

  765. Donna Wardell –

    Great product & fast shipping

  766. Kristi S. –

    This is my absolute favorite eyeliner. It is hard to find but worth the search.

  767. silviaaldaz2001 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    I like the shade

  768. jasmindorta1252 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Great shade and lasts me longer than other eyeliners

  769. devin_burner –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    I love how long lasting it is but occasionally a piece of glitter will get into my eye

  770. Eliamelia –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    I love this pencil

  771. paigelknowles –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    I got the brown and it’s beautiful!

  772. chicatsun –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    This might actually work for me

  773. JennF- –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Like the bit of added glitter and does not smear as bad when crying

  774. madhu1312 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    use it everyday!

  775. elizabethaine –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    not as good at using this kind

  776. suzheathershaw –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Really like how this one goes on – liked a lot

  777. bianca082535 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    So itÕs a great liner love the sparkle in it. But it says itÕs water proof but it runs really bad! CanÕt pull a half day at work with it on without it running.

  778. artsybrat –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Love it!! Sharp lines that stay!

  779. Kiltmker –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    This doesn’t go on as smooth as I wish but it is nice.

  780. sheilawoodyherrera –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Loved it tho

  781. Jillianclaire690 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    nice eyeliner

  782. Christiana_Marie –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Pretty shade!

  783. laurajjo –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    I love the glittery brown shade of this LOCK eyeliner!!

  784. corinnadiehl76 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Love the shade

  785. amott003 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Love using this stuff on my eyebrows!

  786. cprowling –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Very pretty

  787. lbharmon1 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Beautiful pearl- would enjoy either color-for everyday or dramatic look

  788. hahnnahlulu –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Beautiful

  789. kroberts33390 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    cool effect with the glitter.

  790. ashleyuygur –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    I really just love a smooth, potent eyeliner pencil. Pencils are the best imo!! Thank you ipsy C:

  791. mjaz_94 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    ItÕs a replay nice black eyeliner

  792. etwilliams1302_tw –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Goes on great. Looks flawless. Doesn’t last as long as I would like!

  793. sallybaucom –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Runs a little through out the day

  794. the4meiers –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    I think this is the best wearing eyeliner I’ve ever owned. It stays put but doesn’t require a lot of scrubbing to wash it off. Pearl Brown is a great color too.

  795. vstuart124 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Was not thrilled with the shade and the liner did not go on as smoothly as other pencil styles.

  796. sviane73 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    I donÕt like brown eyeliner

  797. robync_nicole –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Easy application

  798. mccownjk –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    I received the shade “Pearl Brown.” I like that it’s an automatic pencil.

  799. rreinard1983 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    One of the best eyeliners I have ever used

  800. tja7175 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    I love this eyeliner. It doesn’t smudge, which is huge. I’ve been using it daily.

  801. kmjohnson829 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    So easy to apply. I have sensitive eyes and it did not bother me at all.

  802. thepatchworkkitty –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    This eyeliner was great but IÕm writing this review 2 months after first using it, itÕs already dried out a little

  803. rayleesmommy39 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Nice eyeliner

  804. katybug95 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Love black eyeliner

  805. frosa013 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Don’t always wear eyeliner but I like this shade, kind of an off-black. Really pretty

  806. iggystclair –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Never heard of the brand before but I loved the pearly brown, I wear liner on my waterline a lot mainly dark Kajals and such. Easy gel liner packed into a pencil! I like the pearly black color too, I may have to try it out as well

  807. moonshadow3021 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Very smooth and different kind of brown liner

  808. agv_2008 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Love this eyeliner… goes on great!!

  809. jamie45810 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Love it! Stays on nicely!

  810. jmilkeris2 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Loved this, it went on so smoothly

  811. Cdunsing –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Loved that it was waterproof and didnÕt smudge on me all day.

  812. heyitslarissa –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Perfect for waterline. Glides on smootg

  813. michelleangela303 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    I prefer black

  814. melaniedpw –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    This looks great, goes on great, and stayed all day. Love it!

  815. ally_nut2005 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Great color, only thing I didnÕt like was the eyeliner kept falling out

  816. teejaysf27 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Looks great

  817. trajam1970 –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    my favorite item yet

  818. s_prusik –

    Reviewed at IPSY
    Perfer black over brown